When it’s time to replace your roof, the material you choose matters. Two of the most popular options for homeowners are asphalt roof shingles and metal roofing. Both offer unique benefits, but they also come with trade-offs in cost, durability, and performance.

This guide compares the two so you can make the best decision for your home.

Cost: Which Roofing Option Fits Your Budget?

Asphalt shingles are generally more affordable upfront. On average, they cost $3–$5 per square foot installed. They’re quick to install, which helps lower labor costs.

Metal roofing, by comparison, comes at a premium. It typically ranges from $7–$12 per square foot installed, depending on the type of metal. However, the longer lifespan often offsets the initial investment.

Bottom line:
If you’re working with a tighter budget or planning to move soon, shingles are a smart short-term choice. For long-term savings and value, metal may be worth the extra cost.

Durability: Which Lasts Longer?

Asphalt shingles last around 15 to 30 years, depending on the quality and climate. They’re more vulnerable to heavy rain, snow, and high winds.

Metal roofs are built for the long haul—lasting 40 to 70 years or more. They resist cracking, shrinking, and extreme weather far better than shingles.

Bottom line:
Metal roofing offers superior durability and fewer repairs over time.

Energy Efficiency: Which Saves More on Utilities?

Shingles absorb more heat, especially in darker colors. This can raise indoor temperatures and energy bills during summer.

Metal roofs, especially those with reflective coatings, bounce back sunlight. That helps keep your home cooler and reduces air conditioning costs.

Bottom line:
If you want to lower your energy bills, metal roofing is the more efficient option.

Appearance: Which Has Better Curb Appeal?

Shingles are available in many colors and styles. You can choose from basic 3-tab or thicker architectural shingles for a textured look.

Metal roofing has come a long way. It can mimic the look of slate, tile, or even wood shakes. It also offers bold, sleek finishes for a modern feel.

Bottom line:
Shingles offer a classic look, while metal roofs bring modern style and design versatility.

Maintenance: Which Requires Less Upkeep?

Shingle roofs require more frequent maintenance. They can curl, crack, or grow algae over time.

Metal roofs are resistant to mold, mildew, and pests. Though they may dent from hail, they generally need far less upkeep.

Bottom line:
Metal roofing wins for low-maintenance performance.

Noise: Which Roofing Material Is Quieter?

Shingles naturally dampen sound, making them quieter during storms.

Metal roofs can be noisier without proper insulation, but this can be solved with quality underlayment or attic insulation.

Bottom line:
Shingles are quieter by default, but metal roofs can match their silence with the right setup.

Final Verdict: What’s the Best Choice for Your Home?

If you need a budget-friendly and attractive option, asphalt shingles deliver reliable performance. If you want something longer-lasting with better energy savings, metal roofing is a smart investment.

The right choice depends on your goals, budget, and how long you plan to stay in your home.

Your Local Roofing Experts in Greater Chicago

At Midwest Windows, Siding & Roofs, we know that a roof is more than just protection—it’s an investment in your home’s value, comfort, and safety.

Serving Greater Chicago, our team is here to help you choose the right roofing material, whether you’re leaning toward durable metal panels or classic asphalt shingles. We offer expert guidance, honest pricing, and professional installation you can count on.

Contact us today for a free consultation, and let’s build a roof that lasts.